did lord rama eat deer

tena tyaktena bhujth Although Even if Shree Raam knew everything, Shree Raam is purushottam and his every action is an example for all. Filmmaker, cartoonist, writer, mentor, friend and above all tireless activist championing the cause of every underdog, Sasi breathed his last, mid-afternoon this Christmas day after battling a medical condition for months. . The OP is asking abt whether killing of deer is justified or not. I have to satisfy with the things existing in the forest and subsist with roots and fruits in a solitary forest for fourteen years 2-20-31 Ramayana So it depends on time and period and based on one's conscience. So therefore, within the vedic literature itself, there is a tradition of how the scriptures are to be understood and that is not by cheripaking verses here and there and interpreting them according to ones own pre-conceptions and without considering the context of the scriptures. He enjoyed eating meat. So we dont have to offer a real animal or a flour animal; just perform sankirtan; that is the progressive revolution in the vedic literature. I have nothing against vegetarians or Vegetarian Hindus. Why Lord Rama is called Maryada Purushottam? - Speaking Tree I am writing here with utmost respect towards Rama Chandra prabhu. Become a Patron at Patreon Subscribe to our Telegram channel, GET COUNTERCURRENTS DAILY NEWSLETTER STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX, Share:Share on WhatsAppShare on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on TelegramShare on RedditShare on Email Our beloved K.P.Sasi is no more. Question: Is it mentioned in the Ramayana that Lord Ram ate meat? 2. the reference you gave where Mother Sita is promising Suraghata Sura also mean juices not necessarily liquor.. He sports with that deer for a long time and when it is leading him away and afar from the hermitage, he is vexed with the trickery of the deer and kills it. Why did Rama hunt deer? objects. Once, Maricha saw them and attacked them to wreak vengeance. Srila Prabhupada when such references at all were pointed out, Srila Prabhupada just took a very aggressive stand over that. Are glass cockpit or steam gauge GA aircraft safer? I call it the 'vegetarianised scriptures'. During Vedic time, meat eating was a common practice in this country. Rama has to take refuge in the forest of Dandaka for fourteen years and let him become an ascetic wearing rags, deer skin and matted hair. The thing is, anyone can add a verse on a website. Likewise Dharma varies based on the time and period. heard about the beautiful and attractive features of St, his mind In the incident with the golden deer, the wife Sita saw it and immediately wanted to have it. 29. vatsyaami = I shall live vane = in forest; vijane = bereft of people munivat = like sage chaturdasha = fourteen varshhaaNi = years hitvaa = leaving off aamishham = meat; jiivan = living madhu muulaphalaiH = with honey; roots and fruits. Did Lord Rama eat beef? But isn't killing a deer for its golden skin unjustified? Now, if people want to believe lord rama was a non vegetarian even after reading this, then god help them. Here again there is not even a hint that Lord Rama or Sita wanted to eat the flesh of the golden deer. Due to the deer, ravana was able to kidnap SITA JI, which eventually led to his downfall. Why did Ram shoot the deer? - Your Sage Tip || --On becoming an amazing silver-potted To That's why when sage Agasthya ate meat he digested Vatapi with his saying "Jeernam Jeernam Vatapi Jeernam". This verse alludes to the fact that Rama was well-versed with dressing meat. Does Lord Rama eat meat? Btw, where is it said that Kshatriyas are allowed to hunt in Vedas? Mamsa can refer to meat directly but it is also known to refer to other things. So Esha or Lord Krishna devoured the forest fire also. : form of a golden deer, and when Lord Rmacandra saw that wonderful Where is it said that Kshatriyas are allowed to hunt in Vedas? Traditional Boatmen of Varanasi Struggle to Protect Their Livelihoods, Truth behind, The safety and security of passengers is our sacred duty claim of Indian Railways, Planning to Avoid Extreme Harm from Floods Should be based on Improved Understanding, Attempts by Religious Obscurantists to Tarninsh success of Science and Moon mission, The Enormous Dangers of Military Artificial Intelligence Reveal the Need for International Regulation, Fractured memories of Manipur through myths, history and personal encounters, Modis visit to the United States: From the perspective of Bangladeshi media, Cuba Condemns EU Parliament Resolution Calling For Sanctions Against President, 2.4 Bln People Did Not Have Constant Access To Food, Hunger Stunts 148 Mln Children, Says UN Report, Mass Killings In The U.S. A New Record For The Deadliest 6 Months, Catching Heat from Big Brother: Education and Climate in MAGAland, A Time for Caution and Care as Floods May Intensify, NATO Is a Warfare Alliance, Not a Force for Global Peace or Stability, Understanding History and Future in Terms of Four Crucial Relationships. Yes. Lord krishna mentions in gita that it is dharma to be a vegetarian. In the wild, what are the chances of finding a deer that died of natural causes? But if we look at, as I said that, the overall context of the vedic culture, it shows compassion to all living beings. Abstention from cruelty is the highest Religion is the highest self-control. There is no sin in eating meat, in (drinking) spirituous liquor, and in carnal intercourse, for that is the natural way of created beings, but abstention brings great rewards. During Pitru Karma or performing rituals of the dead, eating meat was allowed in olden days but not in kaliyuga. ], 4. So it is not necessary that mamsa says that mamsa has multiple meanings. For example in the temple of Goddess Kali, it is said that the Goddess loves blood; thats why animals are sacrificed and when some people say that actually hibiscus flowers are red and other flowers are also red. Sita tells this to Ravana, the demon-king who is deceptively disguised as a reclusive monk and is her to-be abductor. Can't update or install app with new Google Account. Kshatriyas and Sudras are allowed to eat meat. 39. raaghava = oh, Raghava; brahma kSatreNa = by Brahmans, Kshatriya-s; shalyakaH = a wild-rodent with defensive quills; shvaavidhaH = a kind of boar that kills dogs, wolves etc; godhaa = a lizard with unimaginable grip; shashaH = hare; pancamaH kuurmaH ca = fifthly, tortoise, also; panca = five [kinds of]; panca nakhaa = five nailed animals; bhakSyaa = are edible. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? Dr. Shuaib Sayyed, Research Manager, Islam and Comparative Religion, (IRF) says, "It is mentioned in Ayodhya Khandam chapter 20, 26 and 94 that when Rama was sent for Banavas he told his mother that he would have to sacrifice his tasty meat dishes. To hear the answer, please click here asti mla phalacaiva nidaissamuphtam, rdra ca msa uka ca vanya coccvaca mahat2.84.17, Here are roots, fruits and a great variety of forest produce, fresh and dried meat brought by the nishadas., 7. vadhasya = of killing - about hunting; a kovidaaH = not, experts - artless to avoid hunting; shubhaaH = best - birds; naraan dR^iSTvaa = people, on seeing; na udvijante = un, flustered; ghR^ita piNDa upamaan = ghee, gobs, in simile; sthuulaan taan dvijaan = burly, them, birds; bhakSayiSyathaH = you may savour. The intuitiveness suggests habituation. Browse other questions tagged, Like any library, Hinduism Stack Exchange shares great information, but, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. The prescribed rite according to scriptural point of view indeed is to be performed. I think Shree Raam went out to kill a deer. I must to lonely wilds repair, Abstain from flesh, and living there On roots, fruit, honey, hermit's food, The Vedas state that they do not die, but take a sacred path to the place of the gods. Why did Ramakrishna Paramahamsa eat fish if he was Vishnu avatara? it also means immense sense gratification and very pleasant and dear sense Rama did not set out to kill the deer for its skin but rather merely wanted to capture it. The other Vaishnavites disagree by stating that Vishnu Narayana is the Supreme God and Krishna is just an avatar. What is the role of Jainism and Buddhism in introducing Vegetarianism to Hinduism? What is correct for you may not necessarily be correct for me. US Port of Entry would be LAX and destination is Boston. So certainly her attraction to the deer was not because she wanted the deer skin; she wanted the deer and Lord Ram eventually; if Lord Ram had wanted to kill the deer and get the deer skin itself then he did not have to chase that deer for a long distance. However, for these unanimous champions of Ramarajya (Ramas Utopian Rule), a careful read of the Ramayana might prove disillusioning. Muslims are made sacrificial lambs on the altar of democracy in India, The forced evictions across India around G20 events, U.S. And UK Are Industrialized Worlds Least-trusted Governments, Finds Poll, IMSD condemns caste-based discrimination by a Kerala mosque, Comrade DV Rao: Resist Caste Atrocities Militantly, Dumping Doubts: Releasing Fukushimas Waste Water, Why Use of Cluster Bombs for Liberating Territory Implies Serious Self-Harm Too, French nuclear reactors for Jaitapur in Maharashtra- Expensive & Risky- Appeal for caution, China And Russia Should Lead Global Governance Reform, Suggests Xi, Making a Difference Together: Social Media Giving Day is Here, Feasibility of Idea of Uniform Civil Code is Under Question, Being Free Means Getting Climate Reparations Rightbut Not Everyone Is Onboard, In Chile, Having a Good Constitution Doesnt Guarantee Social Change. So those who want to strictly want to adhere to the letter of the scripture, so for such people, who do not understand that the scriptures have a hierarchy and in the scriptures there is a lower level dharma for those who are very attached tamasic activities and there are higher level of dharmas for those who are open to sattvik influences and sattvik activities. Be quick. Would you like to volunteer your time or skills in service? . 5.56. Many kings in ancient days, O son of Pritha, who had constituted themselves the souls of all creatures and who were conversant with the truths of all things, viz., Soul and Not-soul, had abstained from flesh either for the whole of the month of Karttika or for the whole of the lighted fortnight in that month. Where is it written that Kshatriyas are eligible to eat meat? Britannica Quiz World Religions & Traditions Why is Diwali called the festival of lights? In the manusamhita, in the original vedic literature there are some references to meat eating because it is a concession. Controversy regarding Lord Rama's status as a vegetarian. Thirdly, we discussed even if there are some references to meat in the vedic scriptures, what is the purpose for them? The three companions didn't miss palace life, for they were happy to live close to nature and to have the company of the saints who lived there. SIGN UP FOR COUNTERCURRENTS DAILY NEWS LETTER, Countercurrents is answerable only to our readers. Sita ji wanted the deer because that was all part of lord rama's and sitaji's leela. Ok. Then sacrifice a clay animal, sacrifice an animal made of wheat flour. It only takes a minute to sign up. MSE of a regression obtianed from Least Squares. His mother's name was Kausalya. Then, Lakshmana the strong man and son of Sumitra, killing a holy back antelope, tossed it in an ignited fire. Isn't your first line contradicting Sita's statement: "I wish to sit along with you on its golden deerskin". So that way Lord Ram is taking a vow of simplicity and austerity and He is saying as normally if the absurd circumstances be there and Im forced to eat meat but because Im taking a vow of austerity, Ill ensure that Ill live up hittva amisham Ill not take meat. Hindus often have a misconception about Hinduism. Is Lord Rama eat meat? By citing several scriptures it can be shown that our seers or iis were used to meat eating. Its not that Lord Ram had to come closer and eventually take aim. Ramrajya is the phrase used in India for best governance. I want to understand this example. How and when did the plasma get replaced with water? In Sundara KAnDa also, Hanuman tells Sita that Rama has taken no pleasure in meat or madhu since being separated from her. (P) The Golden Deer (from the Ramayana) - Heart Of Hinduism It's only in the case of Rama accidentally killing the deer that she wants him to give her the skin. adhrya carma me sadbh romyasthi ca varjitam, abhakyi ca msni tvadvidhairdharmacribhi ||4.17.37, My skin is not fit to be worn by the virtuous, my hair and bones are also prohibited from any use. Srila Prabhupada is taking even that remote possibility into account by saying that actually it doesnt refer to if Lord Ram even if He ate meat, how does it make any difference? DID LORD RAMA EAT MEAT - Radha Aamisham means meat and it also means enjoyable sense object like kingdom; He says in the Gita, that he is the compiler of all the Vedas. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Then why is that such injunctions are given in the tradition? 2. Answer: Though many believe that since Shri Ram was a Kshatriya he must have consumed non vegetarian food, however Valmiki Ramayan makes it clear that he had eaten ONLY Sattvic food as per his promise to mother Kaushalya. Truth is an eternal duty. Boil this antelope's meat. Rama was the son of Dashrath, king of Ayodhya. Amruta Kataka comments Rama and Lakshmana killed a she-deer for sacrifice to the gods presiding over the newly built hut. Abstention from cruelty is the highest gift is the highest penance. Did Hinduism adopt vegetarianism from Buddhism? But context of verse is very clear, that Rama stopped taking them only after his separation from Sita. I am a practicing Hindu and Brahmin with a reasonable knowledge of Ramayana and some of its different versions. Sign up below. So let us understand this progression and lets look at the specific verses and context in which these references come. drink liquor. :10 Bali, the mighty ape was killed by Rama surreptiously from the back, from a concealed vantage point. So from these some people infer that this means that Lord Ram would normally eat meat but in the jungle He decided to stop eating meat. She says "I wish to sit along with you on its golden deerskin, overlaying it on a seat of tender darbha grass blades, in case the deer is felled." Hinduism Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for followers of the Hindu religion and those interested in learning more about Hinduism. There is no shame or guilt in accepting something which is against the current norm. It looks more like a tradition in the clan rather than personal choice of Ram. Hasten, the day and time are fixed (for the rites), sa lakmaa kamga medhya hatv pratpavn, atha cikepa saumitrissamiddhe jtavedasi2.56.26. Sage Agasthya ate meat during a ritual where Pitru Karma is performed. Answer Podcast when we say 'man' it means humans, not only males. Hence, there is no question of Shri Ram being a non-vegetarian. @atom217 You are forgetting context of verse. ityuktvopyana ghya matsyamsamadhni ca, abhicakrma bharata niddhipatirguha2.84.10, Having spoken thus, Guha, lord of the nishadas, approached Bharata, taking with him fish, meat and wine as offerings.. What are the bad effects of eating non-veg? Souless remake unmakes soulful epic, Adipurusha movie: Ramayana: Modernized or minimized? If Rama had to sacrifice His tasty meat dishes, it means that Rama had meat. So if its a matter of life or death and a person doesnt get anything to eat at that time if a person has to eat an animal flesh that is considered to be an unavoidable thing and so it is accepted. Second level even if somebody says that it refers to meat, then Lord Ram is not meant to be imitated; at least not those activities which are going to give us karmic entanglement just as we cannot imitate Lord Rams activities which are super-natural like building a bridge across the ocean. What is the state of the art of splitting a binary file by size? There are many things which Lord Ram has done for imitation. Why can we eat 'living' plants but not 'living' animals? Powered by. SO IMO it does not mateer ..Rama knows or not & in both the cases the action is justified. When Bharata returns, he sets out to bring back and restore Rama to the throne. Lord Rama was a non-vegetarian. 6. They just roasted it in fire and ate it. 2) As given in Shreemad Bhgvatam they were avataras of HARI , and intention of Ravana was evil. |, || --. Tldr: It is not a mere Yes or No question. |. One common meaning of mamsa is skin of a mango and for example in Srirangam and other South Indian temples actually it is one of the offering prayers is iti mamsa khanda samarpayami that we offer mamsa and what actually offered is mango. Sita found the deer attractive, Rama wanted to bring that deer to Sita, however whilst chasing the deer he suspected that it is a Mayavi Asura, hence he killed that golden deer. So we understood the answer from 2 points of view. Why did Rama went to kill deer? - Your Sage Tip What is Catholic Church position regarding alcohol? Abstention from cruelty is the highest truth is the highest Sruti. a sharp arrow, just as Lord iva killed Daka.SB 9.10.10, || -- Further Rama is a Kshatriya(Warrior Class) son of King Dasaratha. One is that everything Lord Ram has done is for imitation. So if a normal diet, say vegetarian diet is not available in certain situations such a person eat non-vegetarian. on verily alluring Vaidehi you can go away as you like. If he didn't know, he set out to kill an animal which had done him no harm, neither to anyone else as far as he knew, just to get its skin as a trophy. Please check your browser settings or contact your system administrator. Unlike the Abrahamic religions, it is not a one book religion. Are Tucker's Kobolds scarier under 5e rules than in previous editions? Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. [3-68-33], || --, |, 13b, 14a. These were the real promoters of vegetarianism. Thank you very much. He had to chase the deer because He wanted it alive and actually eventually Lord Ram could have taken a bow and shot it, that deer. Is consuming non vegetarian food allowed in case of survival? After Reading this Im very much pleased and got exact purpose of vedas with logics. Nimai Das May 1, 2018 at 9:08pm Hare Krishna, || --. or of sannyss. So like that somebody argues that in the scriptures it is said that we have to sacrifice an animal in the yajna. Lord Rama, Ram, Ramayana, story of Lord Rama, Ramayan - Hinduism Facts 8. || --. 13,117.038c ahis parama mitram ahis parama sukham So it's fair to assume the "deer catching" episode was going to end in killing the deer i.e., it was no accidental killing. Hanuma is telling about, then current condition of Rama as: | Yours is different subject. If you would like to make a donation to support this website. Five Explanations For The Golden Deer From The Ramayana Question: Is it mentioned in the Ramayana that Lord Ram at. Transcription by: Rekha Vangala Because He wants to re-assure Kausalya that actually dont be in anxiety of me; dont be anxious that because I go to the forest not only I have lost my kingdom, Ill lose my dharma also. Rama killed Maricha's allies, but his arrow narrowly missed Maricha, who fled. First level is if you just look at the context of the Ramayana, it doesnt refer to either the section of the animal deer being killed or Lord Rams statement when He is departing from Ayodhya, they dont support the idea that it refers to meat. Never speak an untruth. ; yajasva = worship; devataaH = the deities; asi ahi = you are indeed; kushalaH = skilled (in such act), "This black antelope, with its complete limbs, has been cooked completely by me.
Danganronpa Rewrite Fanfiction, The Benefits Of The Cross Pdf, James Dallas Medtronic, Long-term Relationship Break Up And Get Back Together, Prot Pally Heirloom Wotlk, Articles D